The Norwegian Government has been warned that its proposed legislation banning trade with areas of Israeli settlement in East Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria (the West Bank) could itself put Norway in breach of several binding international obligations.

UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) has submitted a detailed response to a consultation by Norway’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs on the proposed legislation. The 22-page response challenges the Ministry’s assertion that international law requires Norway to introduce such a ban.
UKLFI’s response argues that, if enacted, the proposed law would be likely to breach:
- the EFTA-Israel Free Trade Agreement;
- Norway’s bilateral Agreement on Agricultural Products with Israel;
- the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT);
- the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS); and
- the WTO Agreement on Agriculture.
The proposed legislation would also expose companies complying with the Norwegian ban to potential liabilities and sanctions under US federal and state laws, potentially discouraging US investment in Norway.
ICJ Advisory Opinion does not require Norway to impose a trade ban
The Norwegian consultation relies heavily on the International Court of Justice’s 2024 Advisory Opinion concerning the West Bank.
UKLFI argues that the Advisory Opinion does not require Norway to enact the proposed legislation. In particular, the Opinion does not impose a specific obligation on States to prohibit private trade in goods or services originating in Israeli communities in East Jerusalem or Judea and Samaria.
The response points out that the 2024 Opinion refers to States abstaining from certain economic or trade dealings with the State of Israel concerning the Occupied Palestinian Territory. It does not require States to legislate to prevent private parties from trading with businesses operating in the areas covered by Norway’s proposed ban.
UKLFI also challenges the Norwegian Government’s reliance on UN Security Council resolutions and non-binding UN reports. It argues that these cannot create new binding treaty obligations for Norway or displace Norway’s existing obligations under international trade agreements.
Proposed ban could breach WTO rules
A central part of UKLFI’s submission concerns the WTO.
The Norwegian consultation accepts that import and export prohibitions are, as a general rule, contrary to WTO agreements, but argues that WTO obligations do not apply to trade with Israel outside its pre-1967 borders.
UKLFI disputes this interpretation. It argues that WTO law adopts a functional approach to territory, focusing on the actual exercise of customs and tariff authority rather than questions of sovereignty or territorial title.
Moreover, UKLFI argues that even if Norway’s narrower interpretation of Israeli territory were accepted, the proposed legislation would still breach Article XI of GATT, because it would prohibit imports from Israeli territory within the Green Line of goods which originated in East Jerusalem, Judea or Samaria and are in free circulation within the Green Line pursuant to the Paris Protocol annexed to the Oslo II Accord. Similar issues arise under the WTO Agreement on Agriculture.
Trade agreements with Israel
UKLFI also challenges the Ministry’s interpretation of the EFTA-Israel Free Trade Agreement.
Article 32 provides that the Agreement applies to the “territories of the Parties” but does not define those territories as being limited to the pre-1967 armistice lines. UKLFI argues that there is no basis for simply assuming such a limitation.
The submission further points out that goods produced in areas of Israeli settlement are commonly transferred into Israeli territory within the Green Line and are in free circulation there before being exported. Article 7 of the EFTA-Israel FTA prohibits quantitative restrictions on trade between EFTA States and Israel and does not limit that prohibition to goods originating within particular territorial boundaries.
UKLFI therefore concludes that Norway would be likely to breach both the EFTA-Israel FTA and its bilateral Agricultural Agreement if the proposed law were enacted.
Businesses in the West Bank employ thousands of Palestinians
UKLFI also highlights the likely impact of the proposed ban on Palestinians.
The submission stresses that much of the trade described as “trade with settlements” is actually trade with private businesses operating near Israeli communities, rather than with settlements as such. Those businesses employ both Israelis and Palestinians.
According to figures from the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics cited in UKLFI’s response, approximately 17,600 Palestinians were employed in areas of Israeli settlement in the West Bank in the second quarter of 2026, earning on average twice the salaries paid by Palestinian employers. Before October 2023, the number was reported as approximately 25,000.
UKLFI argues that these jobs are particularly important at a time when unemployment in the West Bank has risen sharply. It therefore warns that a boycott could harm precisely the Palestinian workers and families whom the proposed legislation is intended to assist.
The submission includes statements from Palestinian employees of an Israeli business describing the benefits of their employment and warning that a boycott could damage their livelihoods and those of their families. One employee said that if a boycott caused the factory to close, “the first people who will suffer are us and our families.” Another said that the workplace brought Palestinians and Israelis together and that if people wanted peace, they should “strengthen this kind of cooperation, not destroy it.”
The “Namibia exception”
UKLFI also draws attention to the principle known as the Namibia exception, under which ordinary commercial activities benefiting the protected inhabitants of a territory are not necessarily regarded as tainted by the alleged illegality of the territorial administration.
UKLFI argues that this principle is particularly relevant to businesses employing Palestinian workers and benefiting the Palestinian population. It submits that purchasing their products, importing them into Norway or investing in such businesses does not constitute assistance in maintaining an allegedly unlawful situation.
The Response points out that Norway’s proposed exception for activities having a “sufficient Palestinian connection” appears to be too narrow because it would not protect Israeli businesses which employ substantial numbers of Palestinians.
Potential conflict with US law
UKLFI also warns that Norwegian companies complying with the proposed legislation could face conflicting obligations under US law.
The submission identifies US federal and state measures which prohibit or penalise participation in certain boycotts of businesses in territories governed by Israel. Potential consequences include criminal fines, imprisonment, administrative penalties, loss of tax relief, divestment, exclusion from procurement and claims for damages.
UKLFI points to the experience of Airbnb, which faced sanctions and legal action in the United States after announcing that it would withdraw its service from properties in Israeli communities in the West Bank.
Warning over antisemitism
The submission also warns that government-sponsored boycotts of Israeli businesses risk contributing to antisemitism.
UKLFI notes the historical association between organised boycotts of Jewish businesses and the mobilisation and intensification of anti-Jewish hostility. It also refers to modern research finding associations between BDS activity and hostility towards Jewish students and staff at US universities.
UKLFI urges Norway to abandon the legislation
UKLFI concludes that the proposed Act is not required by international law and could itself place Norway in breach of binding international obligations.
Its submission concludes:
“If the draft Act is enacted, Norway is likely to breach the EFTA-Israel FTA, the bilateral Agricultural Agreement with Israel, the GATT, the GATS and the WTO Agreement on Agriculture.”
It further warns that Palestinians could be harmed, particularly if similar legislation were adopted by other countries, and that antisemitism is likely to be further exacerbated. UKLFI therefore urges the Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs to abandon the proposed legislation.
Jonathan Turner, Chief Executive of UKLFI, said:
“Norway is not required by international law to impose a blanket ban on trade with Israeli businesses operating in East Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria. On the contrary, the proposed legislation risks putting Norway in breach of its existing international obligations. It could also damage Palestinian workers whose livelihoods depend on employment with Israeli businesses and undermine precisely the economic cooperation that can contribute to peaceful coexistence.”

