UKLFI: Supporting Israel with legal skills

Exam Board removes English Language GCSE question paper featuring Doctor in Gaza Hospital

An English language GCSE paper that featured a surgeon describing his experiences in a Gaza Hospital during a war has been removed by Pearson Edexcel. It has also issued a “take-down” notice to a third party website, “Revision World”, requesting that they remove the content as a matter of urgency. Pearson’s anti-piracy team will undertake a global search to attempt to ensure the material is not available on any other websites.

UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) wrote to Pearson highlighting the pro-Palestinian bias in their Pearson Edexcel English Language International GCSE exam paper, dated June 2023.  The exam paper had also been available on other GCSE revision websites.

In this paper, students were examined on their ability to retrieve and summarise information from an extract describing Dr John Nott’s experiences operating on a child in Shifa Hospital, Gaza, during a time of war.

UKLFI pointed out to Pearson that the biased extract, covering controversial political issues, could have distressed students who are supportive of Israel during the exam, and placed them in an invidious position when answering the related exam questions. Students could also have been concerned that their answers would be examined with a similar bias. Students who take this exam as a mock or use it as a practise paper could suffer similar detriment.

UKLFI warned Pearson that the provision of this exam could potentially breach:

  • equalities law relating to discrimination against groups based on the protected characteristics of race, religion or belief;
  • the prohibition on political indoctrination in the Education Act 1996;
  • the government’s policy on political impartiality in schools; and
  • the Office of Qualifications and Examinations Regulation’s rules and guidance.

UKLFI requested that Pearson ensure that this exam is removed from circulation.

Pearson has now told UKLFI that they had “removed the question paper, mark scheme and examiner report for the Paper from access by any teachers, candidates, members of the public or other stakeholders, because we no longer consider the unseen text it contains to be appropriate following the events of October 2023 and the escalation of the conflict.”

Pearson has further confirmed that since this paper was authored, they have strengthened their review processes to include additional safeguards around the selection of unseen texts for English Language and other subject assessments, and these improved processes will help prevent similar issues occurring in future.  They said: “The wellbeing of students using our assessment materials is our priority.”

Caroline Turner, director of UKLFI commented: “We are pleased that Pearson has removed this exam paper, and hope other Exam Boards take similar steps to strengthen review processes and ensure that exams do not potentially discriminate against protected groups, or breach laws on political impartiality.”