UKLFI: Supporting Israel with legal skills

Charity Commission opens regulatory case into psychotherapy institute over anti-Israel statement

The Charity Commission has opened a regulatory compliance case into the Institute of Group Analysis (IGA) following a complaint by UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) about an anti-Israel statement published on the mental health charity’s website.

The decision comes amid turmoil at the Institute, with its interim Chair and several board members resigning as a result of the statement being published. Jewish members of the IGA have expressed concerns about hostility towards Israel and Zionism.

The Commission confirmed on 4 November 2026 that UKLFI’s concerns warranted further regulatory engagement, although it stressed that no findings had yet been made.

The Institute of Group Analysis is a charity which aims to promote the theory and practise of group analysis and relieve the mental stress of individuals by group analysis.

The controversy centres on a statement by Group Analysts for Palestine (GA4PAL), published under the IGA’s branding, which condemns the “pernicious effects of Zionism”, accuses Israel of “genocide” and “apartheid”, and urges psychotherapists to engage with the conflict both “politically and clinically”.

UKLFI argued that publishing such material has created a hostile environment for Jewish and Israeli members, trainees and patients, and raised serious questions under charity law and the Equality Act 2010.

UKLFI first wrote to the trustees on 4 September, questioning how the statement furthered the charity’s purpose of promoting mental health. When it remained online, UKLFI referred the matter to the Charity Commission, alleging inadequate scrutiny of its political content, factual accuracy and potential discriminatory impact.

The dispute has exposed divisions within the Institute. In a resignation letter circulated to members on 3 November, interim Chair Graham Mackay acknowledged that Jewish colleagues and students had experienced hurt and fear. He apologised for failures in communication and oversight surrounding the publication, revealing that a sentence condemning Hamas’s role in the atrocities of 7 October 2023 as a war crime had been omitted.

However, Mackay defended the decision to publish and attributed his resignation to concerns about the functioning and viability of the board rather than the controversy itself.

A Jewish member has also resigned following the publication of the statement on the IGA’s website and an article in the academic journal Group Analysis, titled “Monsters in the Matrix: Pathological Social-Psychic-Retreats, the Foundational Myth of Zionism and the Haunted Struggle for Peace in Palestine”.

The article, by Reem Shelhi,  a GA4PAL steering committee member, describes Israel as a “pathologically narcissistic social-psychic-retreat” and argues that Israeli society is underpinned by a persecutory mentality rooted in narcissistic envy, shame and guilt.

The Charity Commission will now assess whether regulatory action is required.

A UKLFI spokesperson said:

“Psychotherapy patients should be able to trust that they will receive professional treatment free from political prejudice. It is particularly concerning when therapists are encouraged to bring their political views into clinical practice.

“The IGA’s own leadership has acknowledged the hurt caused to Jewish members and students. We welcome the Charity Commission’s intervention and hope it will ensure that the trustees uphold their legal responsibilities and restore confidence in the organisation.”