A letter sent by Amnesty International to UK local councils urging them to engage in BDS has been criticised as erroneous and as promoting unlawful action.
Amnesty International’s letter asked local councils to “adopt a procurement policy that excludes all goods sourced from Israel’s illegal settlements in Occupied Palestinian Territory (OPT) and excludes tenderers that do business with settlements in light of their illegality as confirmed by the International Court of Justice in their Advisory Opinion of 19 July 2024.”

UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) is writing to all UK local councils, setting out why Amnesty International’s letter is incorrect in its view. Jonathan Turner, Chief Executive of UKLFI, said “We are pleased to have received many responses from local councils confirming that they intend to comply with the law on public procurement.”
Errors and omissions
Amnesty International’s letter referred to a legal opinion that tenderers who conduct business in or with Israeli communities in the West Bank have engaged in ‘professional misconduct’ entitling local authorities to exclude them under the applicable legislation on public procurement.
However, this opinion did not mention the most relevant legal judgments interpreting this term in the context of public procurement. According to these judgments, this ground for exclusion enables public authorities to reject tenderers whose misconduct undermines their reliability as a contracting party.
UKLFI’s letter points out that conducting business directly or indirectly with occupied or disputed territories does not make a business unreliable as a contracting party. Indeed, many well-known and reliable companies conduct business directly with such territories.
Furthermore, as the UK Supreme Court observed in Richardson v DPP [2014] UKSC 8, a company does not necessarily commit any criminal offence by producing goods in or near an area of Israeli settlement in the West Bank; and still less does a connected company commit any criminal offence by purchasing those goods and supplying them in the UK.
Similarly in Case 11/05331 AFPS and OLP v Alstom and Veolia, the Court of Appeal of Versailles held that companies did not breach any legal or ethical obligations by participating in a consortium to construct and operate a public transport system serving both Israeli and Arab neighbourhoods of East Jerusalem.
More generally, operating in and trading with occupied or disputed territories is a normal and widely accepted commercial practice.
Amnesty International claimed that the Israeli settlements in the West Bank are illegal under international law as determined by the UN Security Council (UNSC) and the International Court of Justice (ICJ).
However, UKLFI’s letter points out that the UNSC is not a court or a tribunal and has no legal right or mandate to determine whether something is or is not illegal under international law. It has no fact-finding powers of its own and is ultimately a political body.
Additionally, the suggestion by Amnesty International that the ICJ’s non-binding advisory opinion requires other States to stop trading with businesses that operate in the West Bank is incorrect in UKLFI’s view. While the majority opinion of the ICJ advised that other States must not aid or assist in maintaining the State of Israel’s allegedly illegal presence in the occupied territories, this does not create a legal obligation to take positive action such as stopping trade with businesses which operate in the West Bank.
According to a published opinion of Professor James Crawford, States are only prohibited from directly aiding specific wrongful acts or internationally recognising an unlawful situation. Normal economic activity is in principle lawful, especially if it benefits the local population.
Unlawful requests
With regard to Amnesty International’s requests, UKLFI notes that exclusion of suppliers from competing for public contracts is prohibited under the Public Procurement Act 2023 unless one of the specified grounds of exclusion applies.
In addition, Section 17(1) of the Local Government Act 1988 provides that public authorities must exercise their purchasing functions without reference to non-commercial matters. The country or territory of origin of supplies and the location of business activities of the supplier are specified as non-commercial matters, which must not be taken into account.
UKLFI’s letter also notes that many territories around the world are currently disputed, including Western Sahara and Northern Cyprus. Yet, many leading multinational companies and other businesses operate in these territories. It would therefore be discriminatory to exclude procurement from companies because they operate in areas of the West Bank under Israeli administration without also excluding procurement from businesses operating in other occupied or disputed territories such as Western Sahara and Northern Cyprus. According to UKLFI, this would breach section 29(6) of the Equality Act 2010.
UKLFI’s letter urges Councils to ensure that Councillors are correctly advised as to the legal position if a proposal is made to boycott companies based on the information in the Amnesty letter.

